Cigar Review: Plasencia Reserva Organica

Size: 6.25×44, Corona

Wrapper: Nicaraguan

Binder: Nicaraguan

Filler: Nicaraguan

Strength: Mild

Price: Box of 20, $127.99

Grade: 8.5

This 100% certified organic cigar from Nestor Plasencia, Jr. is a mild bodied Nicaraguan puro and is available in 7 sizes: 6×50 (Toro), 6.25×44 (Corona), 6.25×52 (Piramide), 4.75×52 (Robusto), 7×48 (Churchill), 4.5×36 (Nesticos), and 4.25×40 (Tins). Utilizing pre-Columbian farming methods, these tobaccos come from two regions of Nicaragua and the cigars are aged for a minimum of three years. The Plasencia is distributed by Indian Head Cigar out of Miami.

For an interview of Nestor’s decision to create this organic cigar, click here.

Gary from Famous Smoke Shop sent us a Test Flight of the Plasencia to try, which includes 10 total cigars, with two each of 5 of the 7 sizes. Working through the samples, the Corona was definitely my favorite size of the 5, and the flavor seemed to be more pronounced in the smaller size. Now, on to the review.

Pre-light, 1.8:
A simple triple cap footed with a cedar sleeve and topped with a bright yellow and blue band, this cigar has a striking appearance. The medium brown wrapper is solid throughout with no soft spots, a slight plume, and minimal veins that sit flush with the wrapper. There are a couple color spots toward the middle of the cigar, but overall this is an elegantly clean cigar. The aroma is of sweet peppermint while the pre-light pull reveals a syrupy flavor that is surprisingly thick. The draw has a pleasant resistance and pulls very cleanly.

Burn, 1.8:
There is not much to say for the burn – the well colored white ash stacked very evenly and the draw was consistent in each of my samples. I did not pick up my lighter but to fire it up and it kept an even burn line from start to finish.

Flavor, 2.4:
The Reserva Organica begins with a muted sweetness and the overall flavor is mostly bland with some unidentifiable harshness, though there is an antiqued cedar and floral profile that arrives in the second third. The final third has a mint note and the undertone that I had trouble placing identifies itself as charcoal or a burnt profile which lends to the harshness identified.

Overall, 2.5:
At over $6 a stick, there are certainly other cigars I’d turn to first, but this is still a rather interesting cigar with a great burn and a decent flavor profile. If you’re curious about an organic cigar, I don’t think you’ll feel cheated by trying this one out.

(Total: 8.5)


  1. 4Wheeldrive

    I picked up 5 of these from and like them a lot. The flavor profile is right up my alley when I pair with a wheat brew.

    Review was spot on, mild to medium, no kick. This is a linear smoke, not complex at all. I have never had a bad burn on any I have herfed.

  2. heldnokitty

    Shocked by the ho-hum review. I found the robusto to be complex and sublime with an elegant balance of sweet tobacco and exotic spices with absolutly no harshness or “pepper” The buzz was fantastically clean with no headachy feel. Just pure relaxation and tranquility. Whenever I try a new cigar, its one like this that Im always hoping to find.

    • heldnokitty, thanks for elaborating. You touched on some factors that are important to me as well. The corona size is more to my liking, so I hope to experience some of what you describe in that size as well.

    • Anonymous

      Also somewhat shocked by the ho-hum review, but flavor or taste is subjective so no doubt others may feel the same as the reviewer. As for myself, I smoke the PLASENCIA RESERVA ORGANICA NESTICOS and find it on par with many 2-3x more expensive burns with a 50-52 ring. Well made, good burn, somewhat consistent and enjoyable complexity, with some mild spice that isn’t pepper! A nice finish lets me push this little smoke out to an easy 45 minute + burn, while affording a mild/relaxing nic buzz.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *