Our Top 10 Cigars (And a Poll) – from JJ

A couple weeks ago MM posted his Top 10 cigars, along with a list of honorable mentions and a Top 5 list of new release cigars. I’m following up his lead with my own list, organized in the same format. As MM stated, our lists are a bit different, as he prefers milder smokes and I prefer more full bodied smokes.

Also, though one cigar may have scored higher when originally reviewed, that doesn’t necessarily mean it ranks higher on these lists. We take into account a feature that isn’t always considered on a cigar review – how often we’ve smoked the cigar throughout the year. When you initially review a cigar, you never know how it’s going to make its way into your daily smoking routine.

To view his list click here.

Top 10 Cigars:

1. Diesel Unholy Cocktail, 5 X 56 (Review)

2. La Traviata Maduro, 5 X 50 (Review)

3. E.P. Carrillo Core Line, 4 7/8 X 50 (Review)

4. San Lotano Maduro, Habano, and Connecticut, 5 X 52 (Review)

5. Rocky Patel 15th Anniversary, 6 X 46 (Review)

6. AVO Limited Edition 2010, 5.5 X 55 (Review)

7. 13th Floor Foundation Series, 5 X 50 (Review)

8. Berger & Argenti Entubar Quad Maduro, 4 5/8 X 48 (Review)

9. Nestor Miranda Special Selection, 4 1/2 X 50 (Review)

10. Diesel Unlimited, 5 1/2 X 54 (Review)

Top 5 New Cigar Releases:

1. La Traviata Maduro, 5 X 50 (Review)

2. E.P. Carrillo Core Line, 4 7/8 X 50 (Review)

3. San Lotano Maduro, Habano, and Connecticut, 5 X 52 (Review)

4. Rocky Patel 15th Anniversary, 6 X 46 (Review)

5. AVO Limited Edition 2010, 5.5 X 55 (Review)

Honorable Mentions:

1. Casa Magna Colorado, 5 1/2 X 52 (Review)

2. Los Nietos Luca Del Toro, 6 X 54 (Review)

3. La Gloria Cubana Artesanos De Tabaqueros, 6 X 52 (Review)

4. Cubao, 5 1/2 X 52 (Review)

5. Sosa, 5 X 50 (Review)

[poll id=”11″]